
If you have a lot of friends, do yourself a favor next year and host a holiday cookie exchange. Oh, the comraderie, the scrummy-ness. Here's how it works: you make a lot of one or two types of cookies (we said 4 dozen each). You set out about a dozen for noshing and then put out the rest for everyone to take home. You end up with an amazing variety, which makes for a lovely holiday cookie platter. I had a database for ours, which is a little OCD, but that meant that we had only one batch of each kind of cookies.
The haul:
Forget Me Nots (created by Emeril or by Courtney's mom?)
Chocolate-Orange Lingers
Monster Cookies
Peppermint Meringues with Chocolate Filling
Chocolate Peppermint Swirls
Gingersnaps
Gluten-free Sunshine Drops (We saw the Clabber Girl factory while we were in Terre Haute, and I really wanted to visit, for some strange reason. The gift shop looked too cute, and I liked how the factory was still right in the downtown area.)
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Snickerdoodles
Gluten Free Snickerdoodles
Chocolate Chip with nuts
Mint Chocolate Chip
Rugelach (Oh, I'm so excited to find that Mollie Katzen has a site online!)
World Peace Cookies (a lovely chocolatey sliced cookie)
Sugar star cookie sandwiches with orange cream filling and dipped in chocolate. (Tanya, you must make more of these next year!)
I made sugar cookies with buttercream frosting and cranberry pistachio cookies. Sugar cookies are a must-do around here for the holidays. My mom always made them, but we never frosted them. We'd just sprinkle them with green and red sugar. I think my mom must have used a recipe out of Betty Crocker. I had tried many different recipes over the years, but my favorite by far is this one, originally made for me by a student's mother my first year of teaching, 9 years ago. I begged Amy for the recipe for the rest of the year, and she finally came through sometime that spring. I make them every year without fail. Aidan's been helping since he was 2. They come out very sweet, not too crispy and not too soft. Very buttery and almondy.

Sugar Cookies
1 cup butter
1.5 cups powdered sugar
1 egg
1 tsp. vanilla
.5 tsp almond flavoring
1 tsp cream of tarter
2.5 cups flour
1 tsp baking soda
1. Cream soft butter and sugar in mixing bowl.
2. Beat in egg and flavorings.
3. Sift in dry ingredients.
4. Refrigerate for 2-3 hours.
5. Roll on floured surface and cut out using cookie cutters.
5. Bake at 375 for 7-10 minutes.
I make these with a buttercream frosting that's usually for a cake, from the back of the C&H box. I don't like the crunchy weirdness that makes the typical meringue-type flooded sugar cookie so pretty. Using an offset spatula makes them look a little neater, but we're going mostly for taste here. I stopped dying my frosting b/c I can really taste food dye when it's used in that way, and it freaks me out a bit. I use colored sprinkles on white frosting instead.
I also made Pistachio-Cranberry cookies, which I've been wanting to try for myself since my friend Vivian (a wonderful cook and hostess) served them at her Christmas dinner 2 years ago. I think she got the recipe out of the LA times. I love the sweet/salty flavor and the texture is just awesome.
Pistachio-Cranberry Cookies
1 3/4 cups flour
1 tsp baking powder
3/4 tsp baking soda
1/2 tsp kosher salt
3/4 cup (1 1/2 sticks) unsalted butter, soft
1 cup packed brown sugar
1 large egg
1 tsp vanilla
1 cup shelled salted pistachios, coarsely chopped
1/2 cup dried cranberries
1. Stir together dry ingredients and set aside.
2. Cream butter and sugar with a mixer til smooth. Blend in egg and vanilla. Gradually blend in dry ingredients until well mixed. Stir in cranberries and nuts.
3. Drop by tablespoons onto baking sheets, leaving about 2 inches between each. Bake at 375 until light golden brown, about 10 minutes. Remove from oven and let stand 2 minutes, then transfer to a rack to cool completely.
The Art of Cookies
I've learned, though trial and error, some tips about cookie-making over the years. Of course, some recipes are just bad...too much butter, not enough flour, etc, and not amount of technique could save them.
1. Use good ingredients. Vanillan (artificial vanilla) is a by-product of the paper-making process. Ick. Use the real stuff! A little goes a long way. This year, I used Trader Joe's Bourban Vanilla, and it definitely added a little extra something to each cookie. You can buy good, natural flavorings from Frontier, a good cookware store, or a health foods store. Using real, unsalted butter makes a big difference, too. (If you're dairy-free or vegan, try Earth Balance, the only decent margarine out there.) Using butter instead of margarine or (eek!) butter-flavored Crisco will produce a cookie that has a nice "mound" to it.
2. Use parchment paper. Easier clean-up and nice browning.
3. Cool on pan for just a few mintues, then move to a cooling rack. My cookie-making experience was a lot easier once I got myself one of these. Cooling on a rack makes for a great all-around texture.
4. Don't put those babies to bed til they've had lots of time to cool and air-dry. Meringues probably have their own set of rules, but I'm too scared to try!
5. For roll-out cookies, the dough must be extremely cold. Work with small chunks of dough, and after you cut out one set of cookies, put the scraps back into the fridge to cool again instead of trying to roll out the dough a second time.
6. Use a very thin metal cookie spatula to transfer cut cookies and cooked cookies. I got mine from Pampered Chef.
7. For drop cookies, use a cookie or ice-cream scoop for uniform cookies. Kids love to use them, too.
8. When you have made a batch of cookies to share, don't drop the whole thing on the floor during your party like I did. Thankfully, most of my friends didn't seem to care. (My floor had just been cleaned an hour before anyway.)
Next year, I want to explore buying some natural food colorings and some better sprinkles and sugars. I also want a decent cookie tin. My friend Stephanie has a really cute carrier from The Mart of Darkness. I may have to break the boy*cott to go get one.
I'll leave this post on a realistic note. This is how my baking scene typically looks:

Too bad you can't see the egg dripping off of the countertop.